I’ve been researching hardware and software for this idea of HDTV through the mac, and thanks to a review of the Elgato EyeTV 500 by the EFF, I fired up my favorite BitTorrent client to receive a five-minute clip of Fellowship of the Rings that they recorded in HD from the WB, may it rest in peace.
There is no way this machine, a dual 500 G4 which was brand new in early 2001, has the guts to play back HDTV streams with high quality. I don’t own the EyeTV software so I didn’t try that, but EVERYONE has VLC, right? So I tried that. It’ll play, the video and audio stay synchronized, and it even looks pretty good during relatively static scenes, but throw in some action or even a quick pan, and the picture gets quite blocky.
After also trying MPlayerOSX to watch the same clip, I’m impressed by how gracefully VLC’s performance degrades: MPlayer lets both the audio and the video get choppy; it was basically un-watchable.